Analogue Radio Resurgence amidst Power Cut Fears

Published by

on

The power cut that crippled infrastructure in Portugal and Spain earlier this week has led many to question our increased reliance on digital and internet technologies. With cyber attacks also in the news, now more than ever it is important to retain the UK’s critical longwave technology that is available to anyone, anywhere, during a time of crisis.

The power cut in the Iberian peninsula proved just how vulnerable mobile ‘phone and internet connections are when natural disasters or deliberate interference bring down power supplies. Mobile ‘phones require masts that are relatively close by, the majority of which rely upon the national grid to provide power, and internet routers always require a steady supply of electricity. Increasingly, even landline telephones rely upon the internet due to BT’s ill-advised roll-out of ‘digital voice’, which will leave users completely unable to contact the outside world during a power cut – in some cases for the first time since copper telephone wires were installed in the nineteenth century.

When internet communications and power supplies fail, it seems that one of the most important priorities for many people is to find out what is going on. This explains the huge spike in sales of analogue radios in Spain and Portugal on Monday. Radio networks were still operating – especially on AM, where only a relatively few transmitters are needed to broadcast over large distances, transmitters that are usually fitted with back-up power supplies. In a power cut, these signals become the only source of news – and reassurance of whether and when supplies are likely to be reconnected. In a lengthy power outage, these broadcasts are therefore vital to prevent widespread panic, and bulk-buying.

In the UK, AM transmissions include both medium-wave and longwave services – both of which are threatened with closure by the BBC despite its role as the national broadcaster. The BBC proposes to shut down longwave transmissions – available nationwide at the press of a switch on any cheap, simple longwave radio – as early as the end of June 2025, and to close down mediumwave in 2027.

If the evidence of Spain and Portugal’s experience this week is anything to go by, any such closures would be severely misguided. FM transmitters, like mobile ‘phone masts, have to be many in number to cover the whole country – meaning that they require a lot more energy in total in the first place, and are more likely to be knocked out by local or national power cuts. Longwave and medium-wave broadcasts are therefore a vital asset to keep the public informed during times of war, natural disaster or unexpected internet outage.

It seems that many people in the UK agree, as the Scotsman reports sales of emergency radios fitted with the capability to receive AM transmissions have already increased since the incident in Spain and Portugal, the cause of which has not yet been identified. These radios are hand-cranked or rely on long-lasting battery power or solar panels, so that they can function with no electricity for many days or weeks. Yet they would be rendered useless if AM (medium-wave and longwave) transmissions were switched off and power cuts shut down local FM transmitters.

Indeed, the Metro has dubbed radio the ‘ultimate survival tool in blackouts and emergencies‘, pointing out that mobile ‘phones won’t do much good in times of crisis. Not only power cuts, but also the wars in Ukraine and Gaza have proven just how valuable a tool analogue radio is.

Please sign our petition to Keep Longwave in the UK, and tell the BBC your views about the need to keep longwave, and help to ensure that we are not left helpless if a major crisis strikes here.

7 responses to “Analogue Radio Resurgence amidst Power Cut Fears”

  1. Martin Clostermann Avatar
    Martin Clostermann

    A blackout did not only happen on the iberian peninsular but in the UK as well ! read the following text:

    https://www.lbc.co.uk/news/uk/mystery-britains-unexplained-power-outages-spain-portugal-blackout/

    I wrote to the BBC: How can you even think of closing longwave

    radio 4 considering the wanrability of digtal radio? How can you ensure to keep the Uk people informed in case of an emegency when radio 4 will have quitted the longwave by 30 June 2025

    Martin Clostermann

    Like

  2. Long Wave Avatar
    Long Wave

    ‘This is the BBC.’ who should know better

    Like

  3. Graeme Connacher Avatar

    The BBC MUST keep this LW service running. I depend on it in the hills of the Lake District daily. We have many power outages in severe weather. Glib advice about local news on ‘your smart speaker’ counts for nothing in the dark with no internet, and all the local transmitters down. What if the government resilience department funded the transmitter but the BBC remains ‘FREE’ and provides the Radio 4 content daily?

    Like

  4. John Whetstone Avatar
    John Whetstone

    looks like bosses at the BBC and the government haven’t got a clue

    Like

  5. Anon Avatar
    Anon

    The key points being made in this ‘Keep Longwave’ bulletin have not fallen on deaf ears. Just 100kHz below BBC Radio 4, the US, Europe and the UK are preparing to reinstate LORAN as a GPS back-up. It’s a kind of navigational positioning system that uses longwave. GPS relies on radio frequencies at the other end of the radio spectrum; just like your brand new SMART meter. Both technologies have exactly the same vulnerabilities due to the limitations of high frequency radio signals – great for bandwidth but atrocious for long distance reliability and open to deliberate interference. LORAN in contrast is fairly invulnerable, and like Radio 4, it relies on three transmitters to cover an area the size of a nation. Masts for Loran need to be even bigger than broadcast examples, and transmitters in the megawatt range are common… And yet budget is being found for all this without blinking an eye???

    Meanwhile, back at 198kHz we are in the final stages of a war of attrition between political ideology and the laws of physics. Guess what? Physics is winning. Many RTS meters will persist after 30th June this year, and I think Radio 4 might be with us into the early autumn. Low frequency radio signals on a super-accurate carrier frequency, with very simple phase modulation for Economy 7, plus the added bonus of your daily dose of ‘The Archers’ is still beating complex digital technology, (pushed by ideologues) for the tenth year in a row. A quick look at the headlines and we see those driving forward RTS switch-off are sounding hysterical. There is no practical reason why this change over needs to be hurried. One of the cheapest options is a set of final stage RF tetrodes for Droitwich, to tide Radio 4 over until 2030; a sensible end date for the power utilities to achieve. Instead, 2026 will herald countrywide strife as hundreds of SMART meters fail to receive adequate signals from the mobile network. You just know it’s going to end badly!

    Various sources were quick to blame Spain and Portugal’s recent power outages on variable outputs from renewable energy. Rightly or wrongly, it’s a consideration. The UK has eye-watering amounts of offshore wind waiting to be tapped, and it will need an effective central management system for all those thousands of wind turbines. What about a ferrite rod antenna in each turbine receiving instructions from Droitwich on 198kHz! The more obvious technique, using carrier current signals, won’t work passively if the wind isn’t blowing! Industrial uses for the UK LW broadcast network on 198kHz should be extensive. It just requires imagination. The asset is worth more working than it is silent, and commercially useful data can be transferred at right angles to the BBC Radio 4 modulation within the broadcast. Longwave is not coming to the end of it’s life at all, it’s just beginning a new chapter. The laws of Physics don’t just spontaneously change because a government spokesperson wants them to. Intelligently, it should just mean business as usual for Radio 4 LW and its listeners, with a new industrial sponsor stepping in to replace the power utilities. The persistence of RTS a decade after SMART metering, proves it works. Right up to the end of RTS we have been getting three for the price of one out of our LW network. That’s good value which should continue.

    Like

  6. Joe Barry Avatar
    Joe Barry

    BBC R4 on 198kHz Long Wave is an excellently reliable signal;

    It doesn’t suffer the atmospherics/fading of medium/short waves.

    It doesn’t suffer the interference due to multi-path reception (e.g. reflection off aircraft) or the packed-band/re-use of carrier frequencies of VHF/FM.

    It is much less subject to “shading” by hills and tall/large buildings.

    It doesn’t suffer the latency/delays of digital signals coming via the Web/Internet.

    OK – so its not HiFi (due to restricted modulation bandwidth) – but just “swing” (rotate) your radio receiver for best signal, and you know the direction towards (or away from!) Droitwich.

    The construction of a basic “crystal-set” receiver (e.g. as shown by “Ladybird” book “Making a Transistor Radio” by (the Rev.) George Dobbs which was a remarkable hardback book published in 1972 and selling for 18p !) is a wonderful introduction to breadboard electronics and radio – “Wireless” in the modern and antique senses.

    Like

  7. Matthew Avatar
    Matthew

    To get rid of the LW signal in the current climate would be very foolish in my opinion. In regards to the major power outage I’m not 100% convinced of the atmospheric condition explanation for it and to me smells of grey zone activity. Possibly cyber, saboteurs or maybe mixture of both. In fact some strange instances have been happening recently. A fire at a substation at Heathrow, cyber attacks on major retailers causing supply chain issues and empty shelves and even a fire at a substation near a block of flats in London the day after this. Plus online banking issues which were experienced earlier in the year.

    We are being told we need to move to a pre-war footing, so to decommission major piece of national infrastructure seems to me to be like shooting yourself in the foot. Long Wave signals can travel very far, so if the UK were to be in a situation of severe power outages, supply chain issues or mass technical outages, we could deliver information and reassurance needed to the population.
    If needed our Long Wave transmitter could also broadcast to our near neighbours and allies should they have such issues. And if needed (heaven forbid) they could do the same for us. In fact, I believe we did this during the second world war to occupied territories. Although, I think this was a mixture of LW, MW and SW.

    For example, in the south east of the country where I am, I can pick up a long wave signal from Algeria on 252 and even from the USA on 279 and before the signal was turned off a couple of years ago, Luxembourg on 232. So the potential of the Long Wave is there. In fact, it could well have been possible to pick up Radio 4 LW in Spain and Portugal at the time.

    Digital technologies can be good and do wonderful things at times, but can also be very vulnerable. This is from someone who works as an IT technician. Just because something is digital doesn’t always make it better. It might come with more bells and whistles sometimes, but confuse that with being better.

    Like

Leave a reply to Long Wave Cancel reply